Conflicts between Generalization, Rigor, and Intuition: by Gert Schubring

By Gert Schubring

Conflicts among Generalization, Rigor, and instinct undertakes a ancient research of the advance of 2 mathematical techniques -negative numbers and infinitely small amounts, ordinarily in France and Germany, but in addition in Britain, and the various paths taken there.

This ebook not just discusses the historical past of the 2 ideas, however it additionally introduces a wealth of recent wisdom and insights concerning their interrelation as precious foundations for the emergence of the nineteenth century idea of study. The old research unravels a number of tactics underlying and motivating conceptual swap: generalization (in specific, algebraization as an agent for generalizing) and a persevered attempt of intuitive accessibility which regularly conflicted with likewise wanted rigor. The research specializes in the 18th and the nineteenth centuries, with an in depth research of Lazare Carnot's and A. L. Cauchy's foundational ideas.

By discovering the advance of the concept that of unfavorable and infinitely small numbers, the booklet offers a efficient team spirit to a lot of old assets. This procedure allows a nuanced research of the which means of mathematical rules as conceived of by way of 18th and nineteenth century scientists, whereas illustrating the authors' activities in the context in their respective cultural and clinical groups. the result's a hugely readable examine of conceptual background and a brand new version for the cultural heritage of mathematics.

Show description

Read Online or Download Conflicts between Generalization, Rigor, and Intuition: Number Concepts Underlying the Development of Analysis in 17–19th Century France and Germany PDF

Best calculus books

A history of vector analysis : the evolution of the idea of a vectorial system

Concise and readable, this article levels from definition of vectors and dialogue of algebraic operations on vectors to the concept that of tensor and algebraic operations on tensors. It also includes a scientific examine of the differential and crucial calculus of vector and tensor features of area and time.

Real and Abstract Analysis: A modern treatment of the theory of functions of a real variable

This ebook is to start with designed as a textual content for the direction often referred to as "theory of services of a true variable". This direction is at the moment cus­ tomarily provided as a primary or moment 12 months graduate direction in usa universities, even supposing there are symptoms that this kind of research will quickly penetrate higher department undergraduate curricula.

Volume doubling measures and heat kernel estimates on self-similar sets

This paper stories the subsequent 3 difficulties: whilst does a degree on a self-similar set have the amount doubling estate with recognize to a given distance? Is there any distance on a self-similar set less than which the contraction mappings have the prescribed values of contractions ratios? And while does a warmth kernel on a self-similar set linked to a self-similar Dirichlet shape fulfill the Li-Yau variety sub-Gaussian diagonal estimate?

Additional resources for Conflicts between Generalization, Rigor, and Intuition: Number Concepts Underlying the Development of Analysis in 17–19th Century France and Germany

Example text

Euler’s definition of function as an analytic expression whose most general form is a power series was to remain the predominantly recognized determination during the entire eighteenth century . Euler developed the concept of function further in his own work mainly in two respects: firstly, in discussing the meaning of the continuity and the discontinuity of functions. ” 22 Chapter II. Toward Algebraization: The Number Field its equation, its formula remained unchanged—hence, if the function was describable by just one calculational expression.

The decision for one or the other side can just as little be qualified as a result of mental obstacles. Moreover, such studies often assume anachronistic views of concept developments. For example, the alleged mental obstacle to unifying the number ray is induced by presenting this idea as having always been self-evident. ). Another methodological problem is exemplified by the historian of mathematics Helena Pycior’s new volume (Pycior 1997). D. thesis of 1976, she had examined the development of algebra in Great Britain from 1750 to 1850.

1. Negative Numbers: Introduction 35 pattern she applies to the British controversies about the status of negative and imaginary numbers is of particular relevance for this conceptual development. It is the contrast between propagators of the analytic method who are committed to algebraic procedures by means of “symbolical reasoning” and propagators of the synthetic method who accept merely geometrical foundational concepts. Moreover, Pycior’s book provides evidence of the difficulty in analyzing conceptual developments in their contemporary context and understanding.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.12 of 5 – based on 49 votes